Crew transfer vessel trapped under a boat landing

The master of the crew transfer vessel was not able to manoeuvre the vessel free under own power, and the vessel was eventually pulled clear by another crew transfer vessel. Some of the passengers launched liferafts and abandoned ship without any obvious instructions from the crew of the transfer vessel.

Personnel were in a liferaft adjacent to the vessel when it was pulled clear and could have been run down. One liferaft was launched incorrectly and did not inflate. The boat landing was damaged, and there was minor damage inflicted to the bow of the crew transfer vessel.

One member of the transfer vessel crew suffered minor bruising.

During the investigation a number of immediate causes were noted, including:

• defects or failures in design of equipment (the boat landing and the bow of the crew transfer vessel)
  
  
• inadequate risk assessment or consideration of the deteriorating weather and sea state
  
  
• unexpected relative motion between the crew transfer vessel and the accommodation vessel
  
  
• the trim and draft of the accommodation vessel.

The underlying causes were found to be:

• inadequate structural integrity of the boat landing - inadequate design

• existing work procedures not adequate to the work in hand
  
  
• the bow height of the crew transfer vessel.
  
  
• inadequate communication.