Dropped pallet during cargo transfer

During transfer of lube oil drums via barge to a vessel in an anchorage, a plastic pallet loaded with plastic lube oil drums fell while being hoisted. The incident resulted in product damage (ruptured drums, oil spillage on deck). There was were no injuries  nor structural damage.

• The pallet was inadequately secured before lifting, and when it was lifted, it was an out of balance load and tipped over.
• There could have been more adequate secondary securing of the load – straps or netting.
• There could have been more and better supervision of the barge crew during cargo lifting operations.
• There was perceived “time pressure” at work.
• There was unchallenged reliance on routine – “we’ve always done it this way”.

• There were procedures in place for this lifting operation but they were not followed;
• There was a lack of clear communication and coordination between ship crew and barge crew;
• Insufficient training/awareness of safe lifting practices with plastic pallets.

• Ensured thorough pre-checks of all cargo loads, however small, before lifting.
• Ensured cargo loads are adequately strapped and secured and “in balance” before lifting.
• Reiterated need for toolbox meetings between ship and barge crew before work starts.
• Ensured better oversight and supervision of cargo lifting by ship’s duty officer.